Police arrived that morning only to serve routine eviction paperwork. Within minutes, three members of the family were dead.
The Incident
On February 27, in Ohio Township, Ohio, Theresa Cain fatally shot her husband, Steven Cain, 50; her 13-year-old son, Ethan; and her 74-year-old father, William Felton, before taking her own life as Clermont County Sheriff's deputies arrived to serve an eviction notice. She also shot her 20-year-old daughter, Samantha, who survived and was hospitalized in critical condition.
Financial Pressure
The family had been experiencing financial difficulties, and their home, valued at roughly $299,000, had recently been repossessed and resold. Sheriff Steve Leahy said Theresa had spoken with police cooperatively a few days before the eviction, requesting additional time to pack and promising to vacate the home. Investigators believe she may have kept the seriousness of the situation hidden from her family, noting no belongings appeared packed when officers arrived.
What Happened
According to investigators, Steven Cain was shot first, in the home's garage, roughly thirty minutes before deputies arrived. When officers reached the property, Theresa greeted them briefly before returning inside and opening fire on the rest of the family.
Community Response
Steven Cain performed as the lead singer of the heavy metal band Critical Khaos; the band released a statement mourning his loss and asking for privacy for his family. Sheriff Leahy described the case as a devastating example of how difficult it can be to identify and intervene in a family crisis before it turns violent.
FAQ
How many people died in the incident?
Three: Theresa Cain's husband, son, and father, in addition to Theresa herself.
Did anyone survive?
Yes. Theresa's 20-year-old daughter, Samantha, survived after being shot and was hospitalized in critical condition.
What prompted the incident?
Authorities believe ongoing financial pressure and an imminent eviction were contributing factors.