A judge ordered her to hand her son back to his father by Friday evening. Instead, she spent the weekend hiding him. By Sunday, both of her children were dead.
The Custody Dispute
Brandy Hutchins and her ex-husband, who had traveled from Maine, were in the middle of a custody dispute over their 10-year-old son, Aiden, in Polk County, Florida. A judge ordered Hutchins to hand over custody to the boy's father by 6 p.m. on a Friday. According to Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd, she did not comply, and Aiden could not be located over the following days despite efforts by investigators, friends, and his father to find him.
The Discovery
On Sunday, authorities responded to a call that led them to a mobile home in the Waverly neighborhood of Lake Wales, where Hutchins was found along with Aiden and her 19-year-old daughter, who had a different father. Sheriff Judd said the investigation indicated Hutchins had killed both of her children before taking her own life.
No Warning Signs
Sheriff Judd said there had been no indication of violence or threats in the court proceedings, no criminal history, and no prior mental health holds involving Hutchins. "There was absolutely zero evidence in the court order or testimony that there was any violence or threat of violence or a danger," he said.
The Aftermath
Aiden's father shared a tribute to his son on social media following the deaths. Sheriff Judd described the case as one of the most difficult his department has responded to, noting the routine nature of the custody order compared to its outcome.
FAQ
What prompted the killings?
Investigators say the deaths followed Brandy Hutchins' refusal to comply with a court order to hand over custody of her 10-year-old son to his father.
Were there warning signs beforehand?
Authorities said there was no criminal history, prior violence, or mental health holds on record that would have predicted the outcome.
How did Brandy Hutchins die?
She died by suicide after killing her two children, according to investigators.
If you or someone you know is struggling, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available by call or text at 988.